Research
Case Studies
In TRANSFORM we are interested in productive learning practice in higher education. Understanding productive learning practice in this context is constrained by the community of practice in which the student is to be acculturated. A main goal of higher education is to introduce and connect students to a community of practice in different knowledge disciplines and to ensure that they master key concepts, methodologies and knowledge forms in their discipline.
Productive Learning Practice - A discussion based on two case studies
Sølvi Lillejord & Olga Dysthe
Paper presented at the 1st ISCAR conference in Seville 20-24 September 2005
In this paper we frame productive learning in a sociocultural perspective to show how it ties into a cluster of concepts on activity and transformation and clarifies the relation between learning processes and learning product. Based on two case studies, one from a campus-based Master in Education, the other from a web-based version of the same programme, we show that to understand learning as action entails that we must develop the students' argumentative competency. Activities do not per se support productive learning. Educational activities may be reproductive, unproductive and even counterproductive.
With reference to Bakhtin, we argue that students in higher education should be exposed to the divergent voices and conflicting perspectives of the research community. The challenge is to structure multivoiced productive learning processes that are conducive for the learning outcomes.
THE STUDIES
Learning in technology enhanced learning environments comprises
new ways of interaction and communication between learners,
between learners and their instructors, and in some cases between
others with shared interests. The individual learner is challenged
not only with developing knowledge in their discipline, but is
challenged to appropriate new technology and to develop new
higher-order skills. In this project we study how technology is
used in different learning environments. In particular we focus
on disciplines where technology is used:
2. to support learning where there is a tight connection between ermerging knowledge within a domain and the learning resources; where the student experiences the emerging knowledge first hand.
3. to investigate how scientific visualizations, as an integrated part of the scientific discipline, are used in meteorology. In particular the focus is on how such scientific visualizations make complex models visible and learnable for students.
4. to explore the consequences of different conceptions of change between what we term historical and activity theoretical approaches in analysing reforms.

